On Wednesday, Supreme Court Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah Mandokhail made an eye-opening statement at Islamabad High Court: Judges make decisions based on evidence presented before them; but true justice rests in God. His comments prompted discussion on how judges contribute to Pakistan’s justice system as well as limitations posed by human decision-making processes.
Justice Mandokhail said during a high-profile constitutional case hearing: “Judges do not perceive what lies beyond. Our decisions are based on documents, testimony and what comes before the courtroom – only God knows whether justice has been served perfectly or not.”
His insightful comment came during an argument over admissibility of certain documents in a case alleging procedural violations and administrative overreach. Lawyers on both sides disputed the authenticity of records, prompting the judge to contemplate where legal truth ends and divine justice begins.
Justice Mandokhail, well-known for his direct statements and dedication to legal reform, made clear that while courts strive for equity, their decisions inevitably are informed by evidence presented before them. According to him, law governs decisions as opposed to assumptions; justice lies ultimately with God.
Remarks made by Justice Mandokhail were widely publicised across Pakistani media and social platforms, prompting praise as well as criticism. Legal scholars interpreted his words as a reminder of judicial humility and the significance of due process – Barrister Usman Qureshi commented on them: “Justice Mandokhail’s comments underscore the core principle that judges are arbiters of law rather than all-knowing beings”.
Some saw Justice Mandokhail’s statement as an indirect commentary on public expectations concerning controversial verdicts, particularly politically sensitive cases in which judges are often accused of bias or influence. By emphasizing that all decisions must be based on material evidence alone, he subtly rejected narratives which challenge judicial integrity without proof.
Social media users reacted in various ways, with many applauding Justice Mandokhail for acknowledging human limitations and seeking support. “Justice Mandokhail just reminded us that even our best judges are human beings requiring trust and support from us all,” wrote one user on X (formerly Twitter).
As the Supreme Court continues to hear cases with wide-reaching political and constitutional ramifications, Justice Mandokhail’s words could serve both as moral guidance and procedural direction to those inside and outside of courtroom.